NAPLES — What some have called the best kept secret golf course in Naples revealed a lot of excitement in a U.S. Open local qualifier Tuesday.

Fort Myers’ Tommy Stankowski fired a 5-under-par 67 to earn medalist honors at the U.S. Open local qualifier at Country Club of Naples. An unplanned practice round helped Stankowski get accustomed.
“I was just going to take a cart around it just to look at it,” he said. “Since it was slow and there was nobody out here, I said heck, I can play a quick practice round. It helped; it really did, especially there’s some holes on that backside, you’ve got to know how far you can cut off.”
It was a coming out party for the 50-year-old Naples course, designed by Bill Diddel in 1962, and tucked away behind Royal Poinciana Country Club off Goodlette-Frank Road. The course underwent a massive renovation, headed by architect Gordon Lewis, in 2009.
Abbie Valentine, a New Yorker who is a part-time Naples resident, grabbed the second of the five qualifying spots with a 68. Six golfers shot 70s and played off for the final three spots and two alternates. And that’s where the excitement came in.
For Andres Pumariega, it occurred a little before that. The 22-year-old had a pair of conversations with tournament rules officials after his group was given a one-stroke penalty for slow play following the round. That moved Pumariega’s on-course score of 69 to a 70, and into the playoff.
Pumariega, a senior on the George Washington golf team, shook it off, however, sinking a 12-footer for birdie on the first hole, then drove to Miami to catch a flight to play in an NCAA regional.
“I wasn’t happy about it — but once it was decided, it was decided, and I could focus on the task at hand,” said Pumariega, who had a similar instance three years ago and let it affect him in the playoff. Joe Monte of Lakewood Ranch missed the green and bogeyed the first hole, so that left four golfers going for two qualifying spots.
Kristian Caparros, a 16-year-old who has verbally committed to Florida, and John Koskinen, an assistant women’s golf coach at the University of Miami, won the final two spots in the playoff. They each parred the fourth hole to beat out Brian Levi, the son of Champions Tour player Wayne Levi.
“It’s awesome,” Caparros said. “It’s a great feeling to have. Last time, I was a shot short.”Levi, who has turned pro and will head to his native New York for the summer, had a 6-foot par putt he left just short. Levi missed his putt just after Koskinen left a greenside bunker shot in the fringe, then rammed in a 30-footer for par.
“It’s funny, the first time I actually qualified for the Open (in 2006), my last hole I hit my tee shot in a hazard, took a drop, and got up and down from 175 yards to make it into the Open,” said the 32-year-old, who missed the cut by three shots that year at Winged Foot, and also qualified for the Open in 2007 at Oakmont.
Caparros, on the back fringe, put his 20-footer within tap-in distance to secure the spot for the Miami Lakes resident. Michael Perez of Weston missed an 8-foot par putt on the third playoff hole to drop to second alternate.
The playoff featured some great putting, particularly on No. 2, a par 3. Koskinen and Perez hit the green, but Caparros and Levi missed. Perez overcame an inadvertent air horn going off in the middle of his downhill 30-footer to make a 10-footer coming back uphill. Caparros’ shot went across the green, and left him 15 feet for par, but he made it.
On the third playoff hole, the long par-4 No. 3, Perez, Levi and Caparros all missed the green. Levi and Caparros got up and down, but Perez missed his. Koskinen two-putted easily from 25 feet.
Stankowski, a 46-year-old who has been caddieing at Old Collier Golf Club in Naples, was just 1 over after five holes. But having been in countless qualifiers before helped ease him.
“All of the experience I’ve got over the years is it’s just never over,” he said. “You’re 1 over, a lot of guys would’ve said aw (forget it). There’s so many birdie holes out here, so I just put my nose to the grindstone and tried to stay positive.”
Stankowski went 6 under on his final 13 holes, keyed by a hole-out with a 9-iron from 135 yards for an eagle on No. 14. “All of a sudden, I’m 3 under. That was huge,” said the older brother of PGA Tour player Paul Stankowski, who then birdied Nos. 17 and 18.
Stankowski and Caparros will go to sectional qualifying at Black Diamond Ranch in Lecanto. Pumariega will head to Germantown Country Club in Memphis, and Koskinen will go to Columbus, Ohio. The 36-hole sectional qualifiers are Monday, June 4. The Open is June 14-17 at the Olympic Club in San Francisco.
Valentine, 30, turned pro in 2007 after finishing his collegiate career at Bucknell in 2004. He won the West Florida Golf Tour’s Nickel Putter Q-School Match Play on May 76 in Sarasota. He’ll go to sectional qualifying at Canoe Brook Country Club in Summit, N.J.
Florida Gulf Coast University golfer Alexander Medinis of Fort Myers missed the playoff by a shot. He was 3 under on his first nine, but stumbled coming in. A birdie on No. 9, his last hole, wasn’t quite enough.
Former NBA player Bill Laimbeer, who turns 55 on Saturday and lives on Marco Island, shot an 82. “Once you lose it, and you know you’re not going to make it, it’s tough to get it back,” said Laimbeer, who plays at Fiddler’s Creek and mentioned trying to qualify for the U.S. Senior Open, which is near Detroit, his NBA home with the Pistons for 12 seasons. “It was fun, I enjoyed it. It was my first time in competition in many, many years.”